TRAIL
Where does intelligence live?
Follow the question from octopus arms to collective intelligence and AI agents, then watch the network metaphor start to break.
-
01Start / Biology
An arm that can decide before the brain does.
Octopus arms contain extensive local circuitry and substantial local processing.
-
02Systems
What if thinking is something a system does, not a place it has?
Collective-intelligence research shifts attention from individual capability to coordination and aggregation.
-
03Behavior
A colony solves problems no ant understands.
Local interaction can produce useful global patterns without a central planner holding the full representation.
-
04Ecology
The forest-network metaphor is useful, and dangerous.
Mycorrhizal networks are real, but popular claims show how network metaphors can outrun evidence.
-
05AI
Agent swarms revive the question in synthetic form.
Multi-agent systems make coordination, specialization and arbitration part of the intelligence problem.
-
06Exit / Philosophy
Maybe the self is a useful border, not a literal one.
If tools and other agents participate in cognition, the boundary around the thinker becomes less obvious.